Reviews Order NowReviews


Without a City Wall – a story set in 16th century Kerala and Europe

The Statesman - 17th July 2000

This is a chance to see a part of India through the eyes of a 16th century English traveller. Thomas Chacko’s brilliantly researched novel traces James Badby’s journey from a small village in Surrey, through Florence and Venice, to the Malabar Coast and the magnificent kingdom of Vijayanagar.

Click for order

The chronicle begins in England in 1534, with the imprisonment and execution of the monks of the Carthusian Charterhouse. The historical account becomes a personal one, as Badby attempts to rescue his brother, Maurice, from the priory. To escape the disillusionment and terror unleashed by King Henry VIII and Cromwell, the narrator, along with Maurice and close friend, Hugh, travel to Antwerp. With the collapse of the Bartoli Bank and financial ruin imminent, the friends venture to Italy to try and save some business.

From the macabre beheadings at Tyburn, overseen by he King, to the intrigues of the Medici in Florence, Chacko spins a fascinating tale, based on historical fact. The assassination of Alessandro de Medici by his brother, is witnessed by Badby and Co., following which they make their way to Venice. The beauty of Florence and Venice are described with an eye for detail.

But one gets the feeling that this is just a prelude to the latter part of the story, set in India. Chacko points out that he had long wanted to write a novel set in Kerala of the 1500s. The voyage, on board a Venetian merchant ship, is predictably exciting, since only Portuguese ships are allowed to trade in India.


The author’s association with South India obviously helps, and it is an interesting glimpse of how an Englishman of the time might have viewed the culture and customs of the area. Calicut is the first stop, "a terminal of commerce and the centre of the world trade in spices". The Zamorins of Calicut, the matrilineal and polyandrous society of the Nairs, and the 12-yearly Mamamkam where the Chavers mount the assault on the Zamorin, are described with great fascination. But what might have been the monotony of a travelogue is relieved by personal anecdotes, including a passionate love story with a local woman.

Intrigue abounds, as swords are crossed with Portuguese traders who resent the English foray into their territory. Native rulers take sides and solicit support, leading to picaresque adventures on sea and land.

The magnificence of the Vijayanagar kingdom is celebrated by the awestruck foreigner. Local festivals and customs, ranging fro Onam to "Satee", are described with suitable fear or wonder. The last part of the story deals with an attack by a wild elephant which leads to the fabled graveyard of elephants, and Badby’s imprisonment by its guardians, deep in the forest.

From the courtesans of Venice to the parapsychic yogis, Chacko writes an intriguing story. His hero, Badby is extraordinarily tolerant, and seems to compare whatever he sees in India favourably with his own country. The advantage of writing about an Englishman’s travels, sitting here in India.?

OM

Extracts from other reviews/letters from readers :-

Minu Itty Iype

"Without a City Wall" is a rich tapestry of sixteenth century history and fiction. The author adroitly weaves his plot around historical facts of as many as six countries …. ……. refreshingly interesting are the minute details that add depth to the historical figures. Some exceptionall well written chapters on naval tactics of the Marikars, the ancient martial art form Kalaripayattu, the social customs and legends give the reader an insight into the history of Kerala.
"Without a City Wall" provides compulsory reading material for anyone who visits Kerala

Sulekha.com, 30th April 2000

His Excellency Mr.S.Menon -Indian Ambassador to China
 
I greatly enjoyed reading the novel and was most impressed by its very strong sense of time and place. The wealth of historical detail … is truly remarkable.

14th July 2000

Dr.K.P.Nair, F.R.C.S, -eminent historian and Director Dr.Nair’s Hospital, Quilon.
 
The book contains descriptions of places in the cities of Italy such as Venice and Florence; in the East especially Malabar ….. of the intense fight between the Portuguese of the period and European nationals such as the English and the Italians ..…. Then follows a thorough description of life in Malabar, of the Zamorin’s opulence, the Mamamkam (it is the best description of Mamamkam that I have ever read), the Nair tharavad …….

It is fascinating to travel with James (Badby) in the 16th century through the Malabar, Cochin and Hampi ……

Altogether a great and extremely valuable book

Quilon 29th July 2000

Mr.Ramanathan Aiyer
T he grandeur of Vijayanagar now only a ghostly memory in the ruins of Hampi have been awakened into life in the novel.

Guindy, Chennai, 26th July 2000

Dr.Mohan Verghese
I enjoyed the book very much . It was like a mini James Michener novel in combining fact and fiction. My son who is born and brought up in the US is reading it now.

Rockville, Maryland USA, 1st August 2000

Dr.John A Thomas
… one of the few historical novels that weaves so many different cultures and traditions together. Most other novels confine themselves to a single cultural and social environment …..

The traditions of the Kalaripayattu, the Chavers, the Mamamkam and the Marikars are very enlightening. Congratulations on this excellent book.

Koramangala, Bangalore 8th August 2000

D.W.McCririck, -British corporate executive who was resident in Kerala for over 25 years.

It's a brilliant achievement and it really held me spellbound. The story was so gripping and the writing so vivid that it will remain with me for a long, long time.

Weymouth, U.K. 14th February 2001

Mr.Ronald J Watkins, -author of Evil Intentions, Against Her Will & Birthright

I finished your book with the sense of loss that I experience at the end of all good books. I enjoyed it very, very much and I hope that you are at work on a sequel. So many plot lines remain to be developed and the land and the era about which you write is so unique.

Phoenix, Arizona, USA. 14th February 2001

While the book is available in bookshops all over India the following are the specific shops where they are definitely available.

Bangalore:

Strand Bookstall, Gangarams, Shankers shops in the city and at the airport

Calcutta: Oxford Bookshop, Airport Bookshop
Chennai: Landmark, Higginbothams
Cochin: Paico, Odds and Ends, Bhavi Books, Siso Books, Idiom, Incy Bella and Casino Hotel
Mumbai: Strand Bookstall, Nalanda at the Taj, President Bookshop, Crosswords.
Kerala: Paico Books all over the state, DC Books Kumily, the Taj Hotel at Thekkady and in the Casino chain of hotels in Kerala and Lakshwadeep.
UAE: Bookplus shops all over the UAE – in particular the one at Lamcy Plaza

It can also be ordered through Rediff.com or

This website through which it will be delivered For Rs.200/- to any part of India by VPP and To any part of the world by registered book post for US$ 11.00 (which includes postage and cheque collection charges.)